Secret Santa Gifts

Looking for a secret Santa or white elephant gift? We've got you covered with the most delicious Christmas gifts around. Delight them with tasty treats like chocolate covered pretzels, hand-dipped strawberries or Christmas cookies, plus dozens of other desserts that are sure to wow.
Tiramisu Classico Cake
82 reviews
$44.99
A Gourmet Feast
$249.97
Vanilla Bean Cake
38 reviews
$39.99
Chocolate Bliss Box
starting at $59.99
Chocolate Molten Cakes
18 reviews
$29.99
Cheesecake Trio & Dozen Fancy Strawberries
100 reviews
$74.97 $54.97
Olli Salumeria Trio & Cutting Board
starting at $39.99
Handmade Snowmen Brownie Pops
starting at $29.99
20 Hand-Dipped Cherries
376 reviews
$39.99 $29.99
Christmas Chocolate & Sweets Box
starting at $59.99
Handmade Peppermint Bark
40 reviews
$19.99
Chocolate Covered Potato Chips
27 reviews
$24.99
Full Dozen Sports Strawberries
88 reviews
$44.98
Chocolate Velvet Boule
45 reviews
$44.99
A Very Merry Christmas
4 reviews
starting at $59.99
Full Dozen Strawberry Medley
230 reviews
$39.98






Overall Rating
The products above have an average rating of 4.5 / 5.0 from 17132 reviews

Secret Santa Gifts

Do you hear those sleigh bells ring-a-ling and jing-a-linging with secret Santa gifts for everyone on your Christmas shopping list? Then you must be hearing Shari’s Berries coming in their sleigh with a sack full of gifts ready to send to all of your loved ones! That’s right, we’ve got Christmas gifts for mom, Christmas gifts for dad, spouse, your office holiday party, and even your lovely neighbors. With an abundance of gourmet gifts you can’t find anywhere else, you’ll be so happy you bought secret Santa presents with us.


What is Secret Santa?

Secret Santa (also known as white elephant) is a popular holiday game that started as a way for offices, friends, family members, and other loved ones to exchange gifts in a fun, inexpensive way. How it works is fairly easy and that’s why so many people play it. Whoever is part of the Secret Santa gift exchange gets their name placed into a pot. Whatever name you choose, that is the person you have to buy a gift for – but they won’t know the gift is from you! So that means you can have a ball with wrapping, labels, and even the gift buying as the secret is sacred the entire time. Once the gift opening commences, each person grabs the gift with their name on it and has to try and guess whom the gift is from. If they guess correctly the secret Santa has to confirm. If they can’t guess, it’s up to the secret Santa to confess or not! But who would want to keep it a secret that they’re the gift giver when they can give great gifts like farm fresh fruit or gourmet nuts? You’ll be proud to give amazing gifts like these, no matter whom they’re for.


Party Time

Keep them guessing when you purchase gifts that are fun to open with their awkward shapes when they’re all wrapped up. Gifts like these that we’re talking about are our extremely popular cookie bouquets! They won’t have a clue as to what kind of white elephant gifts they’re receiving when they see this present all wrapped up in ribbons and bows. Order a cute Personalized Tool Box and Tools Cookie Assortment if you ended up choosing a guy’s name this year! He’ll not only love how amazing the cookies taste, but the fun shapes and colors they come in too! Alongside a toolbox is a couple hammers, tape measurer, wrenches and more! If it’s a girlfirend that you need to buy for this holiday season, then we suggest the Hearts and Flowers Thinking of You Cookie Bouquet. She’ll love how you thought of her so with such a nice and tasty gift this year!


Maybe cookies aren’t exactly what you’re after though. Maybe you’re after the shock value of opening something completely unexpected. But what could be unexpected and absolutely amazing at the same time? How about a delicious and beautiful handmade Christmas cakes from Shari’s Berries? Not only are they absolutely yummy, but they can be personalized too! Your recipient won’t be expecting this at all from their secret Santa! Choose from a personalizable chocolate, red velvet or vanilla bean cake to order today. We also have a personalizable white and chocolate mousse if you want something cake like, but not exactly a cake. Receiving 5 out of 5 stars, this mousse is sure to be a hit!


Traditional Gifts

When you’re looking for a more traditional gourmet gift, consider a classic holiday gift basket filled with bountiful fresh fruit, snacks, nuts & more. They’ll want you as a secret Santa every year when they open a gift as beautiful as this! Present them with crisp pears, juicy oranges, and bright apples amongst other amazing fruits. And the best companion for these fruit gifts is our wonderful selections of gourmet cheese and crackers. Going hand in hand, these gifts make the perfect snacks for anyone and everyone. Another great traditional gift to give at white elephant parties is wine gifts. Who wouldn’t love a nice bottle of merlot or white zinfandel as a gift? Pair these with a box of our Rocky Mountain assorted chocolate truffles and you’ve got yourself just the thing everyone wants to open up on Christmas day.


Order white elephant and Secret Santa gifts when you want to buy amazing presents for any recipient you end up getting, as well as for all of your loved ones for the Christmas holiday. With such an array to choose from, you’ll have a hard time deciding what to buy! Order your gifts today to ensure they’re on time and ready to wrap!